Judith Armatta

Judith Armatta is a lawyer, journalist and human rights activist

PUSHING A BLUE WAVE INTO AN OLD CHANNEL

Can you push a blue wave into an old narrow, channel? Seems a lot of the establishment -- Democrats and conservatives -- are trying to do that. Rather than ride the wave to see where it's going, what new directions it could take us to, they seek to control, direct, and tame it. As for the old guard Dems, they remind me of the Opposition in post-Milosevic Serbia, who earned the headline "Opposition Divided Over Unity." (Hopefully, that will not happen with the recent triumph of democratic forces over nearly a quarter century of nationalist authoritarianism.)

My local paper The Oregonian just ran a column by conservative Christian columnist Armstrong Williams, singling out Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-Michigan) for his position on Israel. El-Sayed is part of the progressive wave that won Nov. 3. While Williams admits he should not be criticized for his Muslim faith, nor "brand him a terrorist sympathizer without evidence," he takes him to task for not explaining in detail what he means by a two-state solution for Israelis and Palestinians. Really? Where has Mr. Williams been for the last 90 years during which the two-state solution has been repeatedly discussed?

The New York Times is no better. To cite just one example, the Times published a lengthy podcast by Christine Rosen, senior fellow at the conservative American Enterprise Institute, titled "Democrats Have Power Now. They Shouldn't Waste It on Woke." (Nov. 12, 2026). In her podcast, Rosen interviews Catherine Liu, identified as a leftist thinker, focusing on her new book "Traumatized: The New Politics of Public Suffering."

Rosen starts by asking, "Are we over identity politics?" To which Liu answers, "I'm afraid not." She goes on to explain that her intent is "to get at the root of why identity politics was embraced by liberals and progressives. One of the things I found was that it was a successful strategy to talk about victimhood after the social movement sort of ran out of steam in the '70s and in the '80s. It was an attempt to try to make a moral language out of a secular drive to create a more just society."

Then she turns to criticizing feminism for wanting to overturn the distinction between the political and the personal. "But this kind of idea of republicanism . . . had to do with the fact that you took care of your family, your home, your being, your citizenship at home in a very private way, and then you emerged into the public to talk about and debate politics."

I was part of that early feminist effort to make the personal political -- proudly, I might add. Before feminists challenged the paradigm that the home is a private space, not to be disturbed by state interference, women and children who were beaten and raped in their homes -- and there were thousands -- found no redress with the police or courts.

In the early 80's, I volunteered for a rape crisis hotline, then helped turn it into a shelter for women battered by their intimates. Later, I directed a shelter for battered women and went on to serve as legal counsel for the statewide coalition of Oregon's 33 domestic and sexual violence programs. I made public speeches. I educated police, religious, legal and medical professionals, as well as legislators. We formed local collaborative counsels. We changed the laws. We changed the paradigm that said a home is private and the state should not intervene. When I worked overseas, I collaborated with local feminists as they took on these same issues.

Liu criticizes U.S. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez for publicly disclosing that she had been a victim of sexual assault. She fails to recognize the catharsis this likely provided AOC, as well as offering an example for others who feel and were shamed by having a similar experience. Does she know nothing of the history (still with us) of blaming the victim, isolating the victim, shaming those who are victimized? Or is it simply not as important to her as having an intellectual debate about economic issues?

Speaking of identity politics, surely years of educating about and promoting nondiscrimination against people of color, LGBTQ+, disabled individuals, women, and other disadvantaged groups had something to do with the Blue Wave's bringing us 18 new women governors, including the first black woman governor and a Native American woman governor, three black women senators, and an openly gay senator. The 2027 Congress will include at least 160 women.

Add comment

Loading